Why is discussion on 'RELIGION' banned?

[CAS]

It's ok to discuss other controversial subjects, but not this one apparently.

Why is religion considered such a taboo subject on this forum? Too much risk of nasty atheists upsetting the devouts of the board?

I've seen topics covered on here that have offended me much more than anything about religion ever could even if I were religious.

Soooo......Food for thought.

 

[Badjedidude]

It's because religion is one issue that is singly most capable of degenerating into a name-calling, online, free-for-all brawl between loud-mouthed ignorant, opinionated shlups.

If more people showed a bit of maturity, then we might be able to hold a decently positive exchange on religion without one view or another feeling that it has "lost" or without extreme butthurtness due to one's personal beliefs (or lack thereof) being "refuted."

I, however, have never yet been able to gather more than two such people (the aforementioned open-minded, mature people) in the same place for such an interesting discussion.

....And no offense to anyone on this site. I'm not saying that any specific person here is immature....but as the forum is open to everyone, it is extremely possible and probable that religion (being easily the most flammable subject known to mankind) could cause quite a ruckus and bring about a negative vibe and tone to the site itself.

Lol hope that helps answer your question.

In the absence or disbelief of my answer...ask a mod. XD

----Steve

 

[CAS]

The same could be said for politics or any number of other issues surely.

 

[Badjedidude]

While politics IS a touchy subject, it doesn't quite carry the same weight as religion.

Politics is the belief in where one's country is going and who represents whom. Religion is the belief in the purpose of life and where one's soul does or does not go after death. Religion is intensely personal...and too many people incorrectly interpret religious debates as personal attacks.

Sure, you might get someone who gets too worked up over politics...but generally speaking, there are FAR more people who get overly upset when discussing religion.

----Steve

 

[cheaptrickfan]

The same could be said for politics or any number of other issues surely.

This is why, for me, both religion and politics are generally off-limits. Too much scope for offense usually.

 

[CAS]

Well I still think if there's a board intended for controversy and heated discussions, religion ought to be a part of it.

At the moment it just seems to be something of a wasted opportunity.

 

[Badjedidude]

Well, the thing is...this forum isn't really geared to debate those subjects. This forum is mostly focused on being a positive place for lonely people to come together...spend some good moments online, gain some beginning social skills, grow confidence....etc etc etc.

The debate area of A Lonely Life is really sort of a "light" debate area. Anything that could possibly ruin the positivity of the site (or could cause it to lose members) will most likely quickly be shut down by the mods.

So if you're looking for intense political/religious debate, you'd probably be better off looking for a site that specifically focuses on that.

----Steve

 

[Minus]

Badjedidude covered the reason quite well.

Though i should add that it is religious debates that are banned, not discussions, though there is a history of people turning and religious discussion into a debate so discussions usually don't last too long.

 

[CAS]

That's not what it says on the front of the forum. It says clearly 'Discussion on Religion is banned'.

 

[Zak]

If you have the time to go through the old threads CAS, you will find out. Maybe it was even before the time you registered.

 

[Minus]

That's not what it says on the front of the forum. It says clearly 'Discussion on Religion is banned'.

That is the label on the Debate section. I believe your question has been answered.

 

[Coverage]

There are plenty of other forums on the internet where one can go and discuss/debate religion.

A proper discussion about religion is usually best carried out one on one anyway. Having an open religious discussion over the internet is just asking for trouble.

 

[EveWasFramed]

That's not what it says on the front of the forum. It says clearly 'Discussion on Religion is banned'.

It says that under the Up For Debate section.

This is a policy that will NOT change so I see no reason to continue this. HISTORY (of the forum) has taught us that religion is a (sometimes) volatile subject that can bring out the flames faster than tossing a match into a pile of kerosene-soaked kindling. There are plenty of forums where that type of subject is "debated." This one is not of of them.
This should answer any lingering questions on the matter.

EDIT: lol, sorry Minus...didn't mean to repeat you. I replied before reading the second page.

 

[CAS]

Oh don't worry I was never intending to kick up a fuss about this. I was simply intregued to know why religious debate is considered such a taboo on these forums.

That question has been answered thoroughly, so thank you to everybody that contributed. I understand your points.

 

[Badjedidude]

Grammar Nazi Blitzkrieg!!!!

HIIIYAAAAHHH!!!!!

I was simply intrigued to know why religious debate is considered such a taboo on these forums.

Lol fixed. XD

About the thread: I suppose it's served it's purpose, then. Glad to have helped.

----Steve

 

[Jesse]

It's **** near impossible to change someone's mind on religion anyway. I have enjoyed debates on the subject before on multiple boards and I will agree that they always degrade into nastiness.

 

[cheaptrickfan]

It's **** near impossible to change someone's mind on religion anyway.

Well, that right there is one of the things. I think it is officious and obnoxious to want to change someone's mind abut something as personal as one's religious beliefs.

Ooo, boy that's all I can say without actually talking about certain aspects of some religions. lol

 

[sinisterplague]

It's **** near impossible to change someone's mind on religion anyway.

Well, that right there is one of the things. I think it is officious and obnoxious to want to change someone's mind abut something as personal as one's religious beliefs.

Ooo, boy that's all I can say without actually talking about certain aspects of some religions. lol

I agree, but there's always certain subtopics of it you can discuss such as was Jesus a socialist, faith vs reason which one is automatic, and many others.

 

[Despair]

Belmont: You swallow mens souls, and make them your slaves!
Dracula: perhaps the same could be said of all religions; but enough talk, have at you!

 

[Phaedron]

If more people showed a bit of maturity, then we might be able to hold a decently positive exchange on religion without one view or another feeling that it has "lost" or without extreme butthurtness due to one's personal beliefs (or lack thereof) being "refuted."

Who says anything need be refuted, except perhaps misconception of science and religion. Can everyone be right? Heres a site that has convinced me the answer is yes.

http://reluctant-messenger.com/

http://reluctant-messenger.com/the_story.htm
make sure to follow the main story which is about Chestor, a young atheist, who is determined to out argue the master, but the master never argues against him.
If you wanna skip ahead to where it gets good: http://reluctant-messenger.com/the_story06.htm