Obscure or under-rated games

[ardour]

Alundra, Okami, Suikoden 5, Lost Odyssey.

 

[Locke]

Okami

Great game. They made a HD port for PS3 last year, I've been meaning to buy it eventually.

 

[Ignis]

A weird puzzle-animeish game called Catherine on the PS3/360
Also, Mirror's Edge which I gotta say is one of the most under-rated games this generation.
Lost Odyssey (360)
And a title I'm gonna start playing soon, Valkyria Chronicles (PS3) one of the best RPG's on the PS3, and one that flew under just about everyones radar.

 

[Tamaki]

A weird puzzle-animeish game called Catherine on the PS3/360

I LOVE Catherine. Not only did it have a good, if odd, story, it made my favorites list simply for being one of the funnest games I've played in a long time, and still is. Call me crazy, but no matter how many times I died tower-climbing, I never found myself wanting to hurl the controller into the wall, because I was still having a good time.

 

[Cavey]

You can count me as another Catherine lover. I played through it several times to see all 9 endings. Great game.

 

[Kisame]

Demon's souls (only on ps3):Fun and challenging gameplay
Nier:Amazing soundtrack and story